Here you can find a best in slot pre-raid gear list for Protection Paladins for World of Warcraft Classic. This guide helps supplement our full Protection Paladin guide to tanking in WoW Classic.
Note that Intellect and Spell damage are not important on gear other then the shoulder enchant and your swap weapon. Consumables should do most of that job for you. The first item listed is the best, with a second best alternative listed second when available.
Consecrate Swap Weapon
Enchant: 30 Spell Damage (Read Consecration under Abilities for explanation).